Our Approach

We do things a little differently at Maguire Agency – surprisingly so. Covering your risks, answering your questions and getting to know you are our highest priorities. We take our work seriously but not ourselves. We have fun while we work and honor what we value: people, family and community.

Our approach and culture help minimize turnover, which means you are serviced by consistent agent-customer service teams. They’ll help you understand the intricacies of various policies, and underwriting and claims processes based on their experience, long tenure and ongoing professional development.

We’re also proud of our history of local ownership, local decisions and local investments. We represent many regional and national insurance companies but they don’t dictate our decisions, finances or programs. We’re big enough to provide you with options and yet small enough that you won’t feel forgotten. As a mid-sized agency owned by the second generation of St. Paul’s Clysdale family, we regularly invest ourselves in local community service activities.